I taught my first tutorial at my current university eighteen years ago. In academia, there’s something shameful in admitting you’ve stayed in one university. Being deeply rooted is an anathema in higher education. I have been on the receiving end of this advice many times: if you want to succeed/ thrive/ stay employed, you must move/ be mobile/ remain unfettered.
The precarity of employment in higher education makes moving a necessary choice for many. (A post from the no longer available blog Stylish Academic includes questions to evaluate your mobility: Am I healthy enough to live a mobile academic life? Do I enjoy living alone for long stretches of time? Can I live without pets?) Staying in one place may well mean re-evaluating your ideas about success in academia. It is not always the comfortable choice but, in my experience, rarely means staying still. I have had countless jobs in the one university: tutor, research assistant, project manager, lecturer, teaching fellow, and now associate dean. I started working in the coffee shop as an undergraduate!
On the weekend, I attended a beautiful memorial service for a colleague, Linda Kerr, who recently died, too early, after living with cancer for many years. Linda was strongly connected to Macquarie University and the National Tertiary Education union. She called the union the soul of the university. She had planned the memorial herself, which ended with fireworks overlooking the water at Clarkes Point Reserve, Woolwich. The photos below were taken by Nikki Balnave. Along with family and friends, our colleague Cathy Rytmeister spoke about Linda’s commitment and generosity.
I’ve been thinking about our connections to places, people, and universities in particular, since Linda’s memorial.
Last year, I missed a meeting of the Sydney-based informal higher education scholars network on ‘Making place in higher education research’ hosted by Geidre Kligyte and Jan MacLean at the University of Technology. They defined place as being about ‘a space that has been made meaningful’ and shared Ilaria Vanni Accarigi’s website on Place-based Methodologies:
We can think of place with art and cultural critic Lucy Lippard as ‘latitudinal and longitudinal within the map of a person’s life. It is temporal and spatial, personal and political. A layered location replete with human histories and memories, place has width as well as depth. It is about connections, what surrounds it, what formed it, what happened there, what will happen there (Lippard 1997, p. 7).
This has also been a prompt to catch up with some reading I set myself, including a call for a ‘placeful’ university (Nørgård and Bengtsen, 2016):
Rather than considering the university as physical architectural spatiality (concrete) or imagined articulated space (concept), it might be fruitful to approach the university as place, considering the ways people may dwell within institutional settings, bringing values, concerns and forms of engagement of a broader societal character into the academic context, and vice versa.
Vanni Accarigi’s extended definition of place is worth pondering. I love geographer Doreen Massey’s term ‘throwntogetherness’ (the way in which different elements, human, non-human, social, environmental, cultural and political come together to define a here and now) to think about the experiences of being a part of a university.
Here and now, I take a moment to remember Linda, and look out the window while eating lunch—sumac orange chicken, chickpeas in tomato sauce and couscous—before walking through the drizzle to a meeting.
7 thoughts on “Staying in place”
Thank you for your post. But I would like to resist the ‘move to succeed’ narrative. I will soon have been at the same university for 20 years (research assistant-doctoral studies-lecturer-senior lecturer-associate professor). Perhaps the trajectory would have been a bit faster, but I have a family and a (second) marriage and would not trade those things for a few more steps on the ladder. We talk a lot about balance in academia…. I think it is important to demonstrate that some balance is possible.
Thank you for your comment, Susan. It is wonderful to hear of people succeeding within one institution. My career trajectory is similar to yours (although I haven’t reached Associate Professor yet). In my case, before I was a tutor, research assistant and doctoral candidate, I worked in the university coffee shop! The stories of resisting ‘narratives of success’ are really important, especially for women aspiring to academic careers and motherhood, or those whose mental/physical health (or that of their loved ones) weighs against moving.
Pingback: A reminder to play | The Slow Academic
Pingback: Writing in company at home | The Slow Academic
Pingback: Imagining research futures | The Slow Academic
Pingback: Virtual scholarship | The Slow Academic
Pingback: Heterotopias in higher education | The Slow Academic